• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Contact

Golf Hotel Whiskey

Golf Hotel Whiskey: for pilots and aviation enthusiasts

Are practical skills tests ok or are they too weak?

Bruce Landsberg, the President of the AOPA Air Safety Foundation, makes a case on the AOPA Air Safety eJournal that pilots across the pond should take note of. He argues that the FAA Practical Test Standards (PTS) are still sufficient for today’s flying complexities because in his words “the basics of not crashing airplanes haven’t changed in decades but the legalities have.” He further points out that the current PTS focuses on physical flying skills and its guidance is fairly clear. Thus, if pilots just adhered to the basics, Bruce argues that there would be almost no takeoff and landing accidents (which by the way, account for roughly half of all accidents).

However, Bruce does criticize the “artificial world” of checkrides where a “superficial assessment is made of judgment or decision making” -  a major cause of serious accidents. He also challenges readers to prove the existence of:

A pilot applicant who passed a checkride after a crash, where there wasn’t a mechanical problem, and the applicant was manipulating the controls, a prize is in the offing. Suitable proof and not just hearsay must be presented (That was a loophole slamming shut and there’s probably one I’ve missed).

And he concludes by saying:

If everyone adhered to the basic skill level in the various PTS, we’d have many fewer accidents. Do we need stiffer requirements? I don’t think so. In almost every case the accident pilots weren’t flying to the standards we already have. Are you up to the standard? Could you pass a checkride on your next flight? Might be fun to try.

Bruce’s entry has already drawn a number of interesting comments – including one person who is taking him up on his challenge of finding a pilot who passed a checkride after a crash – specifically a mid-air collision.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Matthew Stibbe
Matthew Stibbe is CEO of Articulate Marketing and Turbine, the easy, online way to deal with office paperwork. He has an FAA CPL/IR and an EASA PPL/IR and sometimes flies a Cirrus SR-22. He also writes about wine at Vincarta and being a better manager at Geek Boss.
Bureaucracy must die eBook
Subscribe via RSS

Recent Posts

  • IATA Airport Abbreviations
  • Upcoming Concorde and Apollo documentaries
  • Lie Back And Think Of England: London To Austin On BA’s New 787 Dreamliner
  • Video: Parachuting from the edge of space
  • Hilarious preflight safety video for GA aircraft
  • San Francisco Airport at night – beautiful time lapse video
  • A practical jetpack (finally) takes off
  • A man in a hot air balloon realises he is lost
  • Pegasus House: The former HQ of the Bristol Aeroplane Company is restored
  • Vintage British aviation posters from the 1920-1930s

Copyright © 2023 Golf Hotel Whiskey. All rights reserved.